Jackie — November 21, 2013 @ 11:16 AM — Comments (2)
Cheydrick Britt Exonerated Based on DNA Test Results Proving Innocence
Britt Served Over Nine Years for a Sex Crime He Did Not Commit
(Tallahassee, FL) On November 20, 2013, the State Attorneys Office for the Thirteenth Judicial Circuit dropped all charges against Cheydrick Britt related to a 2002 sexual battery. Britt’s convictions and sentence for the sexual battery were vacated and he was released from prison on September 24, 2013, based on new DNA test results indicating Britt’s innocence of the sexual battery and lewd and lascivious molestation. Thirteenth Judicial Circuit Court Judge Chet Tharpe signed the order vacating these convictions.
“I have been waiting for this moment for almost a decade. I always maintained my innocence and now the DNA testing has proven what I always knew to be true. Thank God for DNA,” said Britt upon his release.
The Office of the State Attorney agreed to postconviction DNA testing in this case on September 28, 2012 and the results showing that semen on the victim’s underwear came from an unknown male, excluding Britt as a contributor, were released on April 12, 2013. The DNA testing was performed at DNA Diagnostics Center, in Fairfield, Ohio. Local counsel, Charles Murray, Esq., and Melissa Montle, Esq. and Seth Miller, Esq., attorneys with the Innocence Project of Florida (“IPF”), worked closely with the Office of the State Attorney to facilitate the result on this case.
“I am thrilled that we were able to reunite Cheydrick with his family. We commend the State Attorney for taking an objective look at how these DNA test results impact the remaining evidence and pursuing justice in this case. This is a model for how prosecution and defense can collaborate to reach the just and right result,” said Melissa Montle, Staff Attorney with IPF.
Britt was wrongfully convicted for these offenses in May 2004. Britt spent over 9 years wrongfully convicted and incarcerated and is the 14th individual to be exonerated through the use of DNA testing in Florida since 2000.
IPF worked on Cheydrick Britt’s case for free, including drafting key motions and facilitating the DNA testing. Bonita Springs, Florida attorney Charles Murray was lead counsel, representing Mr. Britt since 2008.
Cheydrick Britt, Florida’s 14th DNA exoneree, with his legal team: Charles Murray, lead counsel, and Seth Miller and Melissa Montle, attorneys with the Innocence Project of Florida.
exoneration,Innocence Project of Florida,justice,post-conviction,Press Release, Charles Murray, Cheydrick Britt, Innocence Project of Florida, postconviction DNA testing
Henry Thompson — October 25, 2013 @ 11:43 AM — Comments (0)
As of October 2013 the number of exonerations documented in the United States was 1,228.
Exonerations nationwide are documented in The National Registry of Exonerations, which is a joint project of the Michigan Law School and Northwestern University School of Law. The registry is a searchable and detailed database of information about those who have been exonerated from prison in the United States.
Samuel R. Gross, law professor at the University of Michigan School of Law , and Rob Warden, executive director of The Center on Wrongful Convictions at Northwestern School of Law, began reviewing data on exonerations in the United States in 1989.
In 2012, with the help of law student Michael Shaffer and many other volunteers, they published a comprehensive review of exonerations on a national scale and launched the website for the National Registry of Exonerations.
The report contains extensive research data from 1989 to 2012. The three help to define and clarify exonerations and the processes behind them. The report also significantly explained in large detail reasons for wrongful convictions. Here are some excerpts from the inaugural report from The National Registry of Exonerations.
“DNA exonerations also take longer than non-DNA exonerations; the median time from conviction is 14.9 years compared to 7.8 years. This is true for homicide cases, where the median time is 15 years with DNA and 11.9 years without; for sexual assault cases, where the comparable numbers are 14.6 years and 7.1 years; and for child sex abuse exonerations, where the median times are 17 years with DNA and 5.9 without DNA.”
“The 873 exonerations in the Registry come from 43 states, the District of Columbia, the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, 19 federal districts, and the military. They are very unevenly distributed by state, and especially when broke down by county. This suggests we are missing many cases – both innocent defendants from jurisdictions where exonerations are vanishingly rare, and exonerated defendants whose cases have received little or no public attention.”
Along with detailing information regarding DNA testing for exonerations and national data, Gross and Ward explain the types of situations that may lead to wrongful incarceration. These situations are many and varied though common themes tie them together. Some of the most egregious wrongful convictions stem from official misconduct on behalf of law enforcement or the courts.
“The range of misconduct is very large. It includes flagrantly abusive investigative practices that produce the types of false evidence we have discussed: committing or procuring perjury; torture; threats or other highly coercive interrogations; threatening or lying to eyewitnesses; forensic fraud. At the far end, it includes framing innocent suspects for crimes that never occurred. The most common serious form of official misconduct is concealing exculpatory evidence from the defendant and the court.”
The average number of exonerations has grown by about 220 cases per year. The website is an invaluable resource that is intuitively designed and makes searching out exonerees a simple task. The website allows the user to search using name, exoneration date, contributing factors to exoneration, location, and status. The website also provides relatively short biographies of those profiled and their history regarding their exoneration.
You can find information about the Registry online and a copy of the inaugural exonerations report created by Gross and Warden can be found here.
exoneration,Innocence Project of Florida,judicial,justice,post-conviction,Prosecutorial misconduct, DNA, exonerated, Innocence, justice, Michigan Innocence Clinic exoneration, michigan law school, national registry of exonerations, northwestern law school, registry, Rob Warden, samuel gross, The Center on Wrongful Convictions
Henry Thompson — September 30, 2013 @ 1:53 PM — Comments (0)
Women are treated differently by the justice system in the United States. Their cases are often fraught with prosecutorial misconduct, falsifying or withholding evidence, and gender-based bias.
In many cases the bias against women by prosecutors, judges, and juries is often pivotal in deciding the case. This bias will often lead to vilification of a woman on the grounds that the crime was committed out of passion, rage, or another archaic nonsensical reason that parrots stereotypes of characteristics of women. In many cases women are convicted using circumstantial evidence. In recent years the plight that women face within the judicial system has begun to be studied by the law community. According to the Bluhm Legal Clinic’s Center on Wrongful Convictions at Northwestern Law School “In 64% of female exonerees’ cases, no crime had occurred” and “40% of female exonerees were victims of police or prosecutorial misconduct”. Thanks to Northwestern University Law School and others this demographic information regarding women and wrongful convictions has shed more light on a significant problem.
In one such case, Cynthia Sommer was convicted of poisoning her husband with arsenic and charged with murder. At her trial, a defense forensic toxicologist testified that if her husband had indeed been poisoned with arsenic, then high levels of the chemical would have been found throughout his body; and this was not the case as arsenic was found in only his liver and kidneys. Cynthia Sommer was convicted nevertheless and spent ten months in prison until she was able to prove her innocence based on ineffective assistance of counsel. For whatever reason, Cynthia Sommer’s defense attorney failed to argue on the merits of the toxicologist’s findings and in turn she almost served a life sentence in prison.
In another case, Gloria Killian was convicted of first-degree murder, attempted murder, burglary, robbery, and conspiracy. These charges were brought against her with no evidence and they were based solely on the testimony of one man, Gary Masse. This false testimony proved to be enough for the Sacramento, CA sheriff’s office to arrest her. Masse later admitted that his testimony against Killian was a lie and he had tried to make a deal with the prosecution for leniency in his own case in exchange for the testimony. Killian’s conviction was overturned and she was released in August 2002 after being imprisoned for 16 years.
Both of the cases of these women indicate how easy it has become to be convicted of a crime you didn’t commit due to gender-biased evidence and false testimonies. In the case of Gloria Killian, the word of a convicted male murderer was trusted over that of an innocent woman to such an extent that she lost 16 years of her life.
This issue will be addressed in an upcoming lecture at Gage Gallery in Chicago sponsored by Roosevelt University. Recently exonerated Nicole Harris and her attorney Karen Daniel, the co-founder of Northwestern University’s Center on Wrongful Convictions of Women, will talk about the particular struggles that wrongfully convicted women face.
Harris was recently released from prison after a wrongful conviction through a forced confession at the hands of the Chicago Police Department. She had served seven years of a 30-year sentence. Information about the upcoming wrongful conviction lecture can be found at Roosevelt University.
exoneration,judicial,justice,litigation,post-conviction,prison, bias, Center on Wrongful Convictions, chicago, circumstantial evidence, crime, cynthia sommer, exonerated, exoneree, false accusation, false confession, false testimony, gender bias, gloria killian, karen daniel, Nicole Harris, northwestern university center on wrongful convictions, roosevelt university, women
Henry Thompson — September 18, 2013 @ 10:00 AM — Comments (0)
Legislative action passed in California last week will improve the process by which wrongfully convicted Californians will receive compensation for their time served. Senate Bill 618 will streamline the process allowing those who are exonerated to receive their funds quicker and with less hassle. The Bill’s author, Senator Mark Leno, D-San Francisco, said “[t]his effort helps prevent the state’s faulty administrative process from perpetrating yet another wrong on these innocent individuals who deserve and need our help to get back on their feet and on with their lives.” For more information visit the California Senators news page here.
Recently, the wrongfully convicted man Carl Chatman was released from prison after serving nine years for a rape he did not commit. Many citizens have expressed outrage at the lack of response from the justice system in regards to Chatman’s accuser. The woman who accused Chatman of raping her had a previous experience in which she accused another man of the same crime. Unfortunately, Mr. Chatman’s situation is not a unique one. Due to the statute of limitations regarding perjury in Illinois, Chatman’s accuser cannot be punished. For more information about Carl Chatman visit the Chicago Sun-Times.
Barri White, a wrongfully convicted man, served six years in high-security jail for the murder of his girlfriend in 2002. In 2005, the BBC investigated his case and found the forensic evidence used to convict him was false and his case had been one of false accusations and demonization. Mr. White stated “I am still fighting, I have had enough of fighting, I deserve a life back. Getting compensation and an apology from the police, that would be my justice. It was six years of my life, my whole 20s, pretty much. They’re supposed to be the best years of your life but I was rotting in jail. Nothing can make up for that. No amount of money is going to bring my six years back.” The BBC program ‘Life after life: Barri and Keith’s story’ aired Monday Sept. 16th in the UK and will be available later online. Information can be found at the BBC.
Ronald Cotton and Jennifer Thompson-Canino
Ronald Cotton was mistakenly identified and wrongfully convicted of raping Jennifer Thompson-Canino in 1984. Cotton was exonerated in June 1995 after DNA testing proved he was not the rapist. In an unusual turn of events, he and Jennifer have become friends and often appear together talking about wrongful convictions and incarceration. The two have written a book, “Picking Cotton“, and are to the keynote speakers at the centerpiece of Miami University (of Ohio) Regional Campus’ upcoming Criminal Justice Week. More information about the talks can be found at the Journal News.
They are also scheduled to be in Jacksonville at both of the Florida State College campuses in March 2014.
In Louisiana recently an exonerated man who was cleared of rape charges finds himself in court again. Darrin Hill, a 47 year old man who suffers from schizoaffective disorder, had been in prison for more than ten years for a rape he did not commit. His accuser pointed him out in a lineup and he was convicted quickly. Over the past 13 years Hill had been in and out of mental hospitals and jails. In 2010, a sexual assault kit that was used by doctors to examine Hill’s accuser was found by staff members of the federal National Institute of Justice-funded Orleans Parish Post-conviction DNA Testing Project. DNA testing revealed that Hill’s DNA was not present but rather the testing revealed the DNA of another man. Hill was exonerated with the help of Innocence Project New Orleans and charges were dropped. Now Hill has to face his accuser again as she refutes her earlier claim that he was her rapist. More information can be found at The Advocate.
Compensation,exoneration,Innocence Project of Florida,judicial,justice,legislation,litigation,post-conviction, barri white, BBC, Carl Chatman, chicago, darrin hill, exoneration, Jennifer Thompson, justice, New Orleans Innocence Project, Picking Cotton, Ronald Cotton, Senator Mark Leno, wrongful convictions
Henry Thompson — September 13, 2013 @ 2:28 PM — Comments (0)
California Innocence Project Exoneree and NFL-hopeful Brian Banks was released from the Atlanta Falcons during a pre-season cut to the 53-man team. Banks was one of ten players released. Banks is neither upset nor dismayed. He noted his performance on the field was behind that of his peers because of his absence from the game and he put everything he had out there on the field.
Banks looks forward to free agency as well as other opportunities. He recently posted on his twitter account:
“As most have heard, my time with the Atlanta Falcons has come to an early end. I want to thank Mr Blank, Dimitroff,& Smith for such an amazing and unforgettable opportunity. This experience has shown me a piece of life that was once taken, and where things (football wise) would have been if it wasn’t for the 10 years of life loss.”
Banks has not announced any plans to continue playing football though he has tweeted about speaking engagements and other events he may be available for. Banks is the keynote speaker at the Innocence Project of Minnesota’s annual benefit on October 17th.
There have also been tweets about a potential documentary of his life story. Whatever the future holds for Banks, we hope for success for him as he continues to spread his story of exoneration and innocence.
More information about Brian Banks can be found at ABC News , the NFL, and The National Registry of Exonerations, as well as IPF’s blog Plain Error.
exoneration,Innocence Project of Florida,justice,post-conviction, Atlanta Falcons, Brian Banks, California Innocence Project, exoneree, Football, NFL, Released
Henry Thompson — September 10, 2013 @ 4:57 PM — Comments (0)
In an unprecedented case, the Irish Government is considering posthumously exonerating a man who was convicted of murder in 1940 and executed less than one year later. Seventy-two years after Harry Gleeson’s death, his family may be getting the closure they desire. The newly formed Irish Innocence Project at Dublin’s Griffith College is heading up the cause for Harry Gleeson’s exoneration.
Gleeson was wrongfully convicted of murdering his next door neighbor in November of 1940. Gleeson was denied a fair trial and evidence was withheld. This evidence is now just coming to light with the help of a new Justice Minister and a new pathologist’s report on the body of victim Mary McCarthy.
David Langwaller is the head of the Irish Innocence Project and works closely with DNA expert Dr. Greg Hampikian, scientist and Director of Idaho Innocence Project. Gleeson may be the first exoneration for The Irish Innocence Project. After reaching out to the the Justice Minister last year, the Irish Innocence Project was finally able to make headway in Gleeson’s case. According to Langwaller, new evidence has recently been discovered that can prove his innocence.
Gleeson’s family has been trying for years to get his case to the courts in Ireland and is just now able to thanks to the Irish Innocence Project. Their years of working to exonerate Harry Gleeson may pay off very soon.
You can find more information at the Irish Innocence Project and the Independent.
exoneration,Innocence Project of Florida,justice,post-conviction, Dublin's Griffith College, executed, exoneration, Harry Gleeson, Idaho Innocence Project, innocence project, Ireland, Irish Innocence Project, justice, pardon, posthumous
Henry Thompson — September 04, 2013 @ 1:00 PM — Comments (0)
Here is a roundup of some highlights in the news recently about exonerations or exonerees who are building their lives after prison.
Exoneree Brian Banks who famously made his way back to the NFL and football recently has unfortunately been cut from the Atlanta Falcons roster. Banks played during the preseason, and recorded two tackles in a game August 9th. Although this is a setback in Banks’ improbable quest for an NFL roster spot, he has not let this news discourage him as he will be a free agent available to another team in need of a linebacker. The Atlanta Falcons administration appreciates Banks’ effort and heart, and has said that there is a role for Banks at the Atlanta Falcons whether on the field or not. More information can be found at ESPN.
In Clark County Washington Alan Northrop expressed his gratitude recently when receiving news about his forthcoming compensation for the 17 years he spent wrongfully imprisoned. Through DNA evidence and support from the Innocence Project Northwest, Northrop was freed. For more information about Northrop visit The Columbian.
After being in prison for 17 years, 12 of which were on death row, for a crime he did not commit , Randy Steidl now enjoys his freedom more than most. Steidl has taken to touring the country and giving speeches on the death penalty and its implications. More information can be found at WDRB.com.
Exoneree James Kluppleberg has been out of prison for more than a year and yet he still struggles to provide for himself and his family due to the stigma of being incarcerated. He explains that the general public does not understand the concept of exoneration. Kluppleberg applied for a written certificate from the state proving his innocence and exoneration. On August 6, 2013 Kluppelberg received that certificate and will now hopefully find an easier path to leading a normal life. Read more at CBS Chicago.
A student who was detained by the DEA for five days without food or water has recently won a lawsuit granting him $4.1 million in damages. What’s troubling about this award is whether or not he will have to pay taxes to the IRS on it. Read more about Daniel Chong at Forbes Magazine.
Sharon Snyder, an employee of a local clerk of court, was recently fired for passing a document describing in detail how to file a request for postconviction DNA testing to Robert Nelson. Nelson had been in prison since 1984 and Snyder’s vital act of sharing information ended up allowing Nelson to obtain exonerative DNA results that led to the overturning of his wrongful conviction. Read more at The Huffington Post.
Under what appear to be shady circumstances, the presiding judge in a case of a soon-to-be exonerated prisoner in Chicago, Stanley Wrice, has just recused herself for seemingly personal reasons. Wrice was beaten and tortured into a confessing to a gang rape in 1982. Judge Evelyn Clay was presiding over Wrice’s proceeding when suddenly she was called to meet with her superior. After said meeting Clay stated that she had personal knowledge of those involved and could no longer be the judge in charge. Rumors abound that Clay’s superior has/had ties to former Mayor Daly’s (who’s brother is currently running for Governor of Illinois) and that those ties influenced the recusal decision. Read more at The Huffington Post Chicago.
Compensation,exoneration,Innocence Project of Florida,justice,litigation,post-conviction,prison, Alan Northrop, Atlanta Falcons, Brian Banks, Daniel Chong, exonerated, Forbes Magazine, Huffington Post, James Kluppelberg, NFL, Randy Steidl, Robert Nelson, Washingon Innocence Project
Henry Thompson — August 20, 2013 @ 3:48 PM — Comments (0)
Along with our Innocence Network colleagues, we are saddened by the loss of Forest Shomberg and offer our condolences to his friends and family. He will be missed and remembered.
Shomberg at his release in 2009.
Forest Shomberg was exonerated in 2009 for a 2002 assault conviction. He served six years for this crime, which he did not commit. The Wisconsin Innocence Project helped facilitate his exoneration and release. Shomberg received no support upon his release in 2009 for his documented addiction problems. Vital support for exonerees is non-existent in many states even though it could save lives. More information about Shomberg can be found at the Wisconsin State Journal.
exoneration,post-conviction, exoneree, Forest Shomberg, Wisconsin Innocence Project
Ileejah Hutchinson — August 14, 2013 @ 11:12 AM — Comments (0)
James Kluppelberg, who was wrongfully convicted of arson that killed six people and sentenced to life in prison, was granted a certificate of innocence.
Kluppelberg was convicted and spent 24 years behind bars for a crime he did not commit only to be exonerated on May 30, 2012 after a Cook County Judge vacated his conviction. He was delighted to be released just in time to celebrate his 47th birthday as a free man.
An exoneration after proclaiming innocence since the inception of a case is ideal, but to walk around with a mistake on your record is hurtful not to mention a large reminder of the negligence of another.
Kluppelberg’s attorney opted for a certificate of innocence after his exoneration; however, the Cook County State Attorney’s Office fought the issuance of the certificate.
Now 14 months post exoneration, Kluppelberg has been issued his certificate by Judge Michael McHale and can finally put the past behind him and move on.
Congratulations James and we wish you luck in all of your future endeavors as a free man.
exoneration,Innocence Project of Florida,judicial,post-conviction,Uncategorized, James Kluppelberg
Ileejah Hutchinson — August 07, 2013 @ 10:51 AM — Comments (0)
Innocence Project Northwest exoneree, Alan Northrop, is now eligible for compensation for his wrongful conviction and imprisonment under a new state law that went into effect Sunday.
Northrop, 49, spent 17 years in prison for rape until his exoneration in 2010 due to DNA evidence.
Under House Bill 1341, Northrop is eligible to receive $50,000 for each year he was imprisoned plus payment of all child support debt. According to the bill, if Northrop receives restitution for all 17 years he will receive a total amount of $850,000.
The amount of money provided by the state is a large amount, but will never make up for the time stolen from Northrop and his children; however, it is a step in the right direction to correct this terrible wrong.
As of now, only 27 states plus Washington D.C. have statues providing compensation for the wrongfully convicted. Under the new Washington bill about a dozen more exonerees will be eligible for restitution.
Since his exoneration, Northrop has been working to rebuild his life and reconnecting with his three children. The new bill also provides his three children with free tuition at state universities until age 26.
Congratulations to Alan Northrop, and his children; their daddy is finally home.
Compensation,exoneration,justice,litigation,policy,post-conviction,Uncategorized, Alan Northrop, compensation, DNA evidence, Innocence Project Northwest, Washington State